Customer reviews for Milani Stay Put Matte Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, Black

Milani Stay Put Matte Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, Black
$9.99
Prices may vary from online to in store

How to get it




  • Holly
    Verified purchase
    Reviewed 2 years ago

    All Time Favorite!

    This eyeliner has been my favorite for a long time. The liner stays put all day, washes off easily and has a great tip on the brush for making a great winged look.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Kayla
    Reviewed 2 years ago

    Does Not Stay On

    Need to bring back Infinite Eyeliner! This is nothing close to infinite. It runs, smears, and is not waterproof
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Yes, I recommend
    Yez
    Reviewed 2 years ago

    I would buy this products again

    I just balled my eyes out for like 40 mins straight arguing with my boyfriend, breaking up and making up and this eyeliner stayed on the whole time, 10/10 would recommend.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Myra
    Reviewed 2 years ago

    NOT LIKE THE INFINITE LIQUID EYELINER.

    I faithful to the infinite liquid liner since I was a teenager and find it disheartening to have this product released and NOT have the same results. Milani used to be my favorite eyeliner brand but not anymore.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Patricia
    Verified purchase
    Reviewed 2 years ago

    I will continue to buy this product

    I have the most control applying this eyeliner and it lasts all day without any problems so I love it ❣️
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Maya
    Verified purchase
    Reviewed 2 years ago

    A great find

    It's not quite as sleek as the KVD eyeliner I usually buy, but it beats everything else. Goes on smooth and stays where you put it.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Monica
    Reviewed 2 years ago

    Definately NOT the Infinite Liquid Eyeliner.

    I was a faithful user of the Infinite Liquid Eyeliner for YEARS! I used it because it was literally waterproof and smudge proof. I could swim or shower with it and it was stay put. When it was discontinued I bought this one with the same expectation, since it says it's 17 hour wear. Well it's NOT. The first time I wore this was to a funeral, I cried... and it came off. About a week later I was working out, started sweating and when I wiped my sweat it rubbed off. I feel like this is just like any other liquid eyeliners. It shouldn't tout 17 hour wear either. Very disappointed customer that Infinite was discontinued, and that Milani thought this was a better replacement.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
  • Anne
    Verified purchase
    Reviewed 3 years ago

    Lasts and lasts!

    This is hands down the best liquid liner EVER. It's better than all the expensive liners I've tried, and I've tried many. No other liner has the staying power this does.
    0 users found this review helpful.
    Originally posted on milani-cosmetics.com
Page 1 of 8

Details for Milani Stay Put Matte Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, Black